🔍
Milk based drinks

How to use a milkshake in recipes?

Quick answer

A milkshake is mostly milk and ice cream, so it can stand in for those in other recipes only in small, tested ways. Reliable uses are as a base for a cake shake (blend in leftover cake), a topping for waffles, or a flavor boost in homemade ice cream; do not swap it for milk in baking without a recipe.

Free download

Milk and Dairy Storage Chart (PDF): How long milk, plant milks, cream, yogurt and kefir last, opened and unopened. 23 rows, each with its source.

We use your email only for this download and, if you tick the box, to tell you about the pack. No spam. We do not sell it. Delete it any time: contact@drinkstype.com. Privacy policy

Thank you

Your chart is ready

Download the PDF

We use your email only for this download.
In this article
  1. Can you use a milkshake in recipes?
  2. Ideas that work
  3. What to avoid
  4. How to store leftover milkshake
  5. Make it work better

Can you use a milkshake in recipes?

Sometimes, but be realistic. A milkshake is sweetened, cold and full of air, so it does not replace milk in most recipes. The ideas below are general guidance, not official methods.

Ideas that work

  • Cake shakes: The Daily Meal suggests blending stale or leftover cake with milk and ice cream; use about a quarter cup of milk per cup of ice cream, blend the milk and ice cream first, then add the cake.
  • Malted milkshakes: stir in malted milk powder, about 2 tablespoons per serving, after the first blend.
  • Waffles or pancakes: serve a small portion of thick shake as a sauce.
  • Freezer treats: a leftover shake can be refrozen into pops. The texture may turn icy.
  • Smoothie base: mix a little into a fruit smoothie, remembering it adds sugar.

What to avoid

  • Replacing milk or cream in baking. Sugar and air change the result.
  • Heating a milkshake for hot sauces. It may separate.
  • Reusing a shake that sat out too long.

How to store leftover milkshake

The CDC advises not leaving perishable food out for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90 F. Put leftovers in a covered container in the fridge at 40 F or below, and use them soon.

Make it work better

  • Full-fat milk and ice cream give the richest texture.
  • Chill the blender pitcher first so the shake stays cold, as Tasting Table advises.

For more ideas, see how to use malted milk in recipes.

People also ask

Can I bake with a leftover milkshake?

Not as a direct milk substitute. The sugar and air change the result, so use a tested recipe.

Can I refreeze a milkshake?

You can freeze it into pops, but the texture may be icy.

How long can a milkshake sit out?

No more than 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90 F, per the CDC.

General information only, not medical advice. If you have a health condition or are pregnant, ask your doctor before changing what you drink.

Sources

  1. The Daily Meal: Milkshakes and leftover cake, read 6 Nov 2026
  2. Tasting Table: malted milk powder milkshake tip, read 6 Nov 2026
  3. CDC: Food safety prevention, read 6 Nov 2026
Written by Drinks Type Editorial Team · Published Nov 5, 2025 · Updated Nov 6, 2026
About · How we verify this · Editorial policy · Corrections

What would help you most next?

One tap. Anonymous. It helps us decide what to build.

More in Milk based drinks

All Milk based drinks ›